Compare your options

Agency, in-house or buying leads?

An honest side-by-side of the four ways home service companies get leads — and when each one makes sense.

Call (516) 206-2802 Free growth audit

✓ Google Premier Partner·✓ Month-to-month·✓ 22 in-house specialists

5.0on Google reviews

// Free growth audit

Get your free strategy call.

Tell us about your business. We'll respond within 24 hours.

✓ Free·✓ No obligation·✓ Month-to-month

✓

You're on the list.

We'll reach out within 24 hours with your custom growth strategy.

Chat on WhatsApp

Quick answer

What's the best way for a home service company to get leads?

Home service companies usually choose between four ways to get leads: a specialist home service agency like MADBUZZ, a generalist marketing agency, an in-house marketing hire, or buying shared leads from lead marketplaces. A specialist agency gives you a full team trained on your trade with no long contract; a generalist spreads attention across many industries; one in-house hire can't cover every channel; and shared leads are often sent to several competing contractors.

Updated October 2026 · Reviewed by Ben Azoulay, Co-founder of MADBUZZ

Side by side

Four ways to get leads, compared.

	MADBUZZ	Generalist agency	In-house hire	Shared-lead marketplace
Industry focus	Home services only	Any industry	Your company	Many trades, many contractors
Who does the work	22 in-house specialists	Often outsourced or junior staff	One person, learning every channel	Platform; you do the follow-up
Channels covered	Google Ads, LSAs, SEO, AEO, Meta, automation	Varies	Usually one or two	None — you buy leads
Lead exclusivity	Your leads are yours	Your leads are yours	Your leads are yours	Leads can go to several contractors
Contract	Month-to-month	Often 6–24 months	Employment, salary, benefits	Varies by platform
Builds an asset you own	Yes — rankings, reviews, accounts, data	Sometimes	Yes	No — stop paying, leads stop
Reporting	Calls, forms, booked jobs	Often impressions & clicks	Depends on the person	Lead counts

General comparison of approaches. Individual agencies, employees and platforms vary.

Which fits you

The honest answer

Choose a specialist agency if…

You want more booked jobs across Google, Maps, AI and social, with someone accountable for the whole system — and you don't want to manage marketers.

A generalist may work if…

You have non-home-service businesses too and want one vendor for everything.

Hire in-house if…

You're large enough for a full marketing team, not one person — and you can manage them.

Shared leads may work if…

You need a few jobs right now and have a fast sales process, and you accept competing for every lead.

FAQ

Choosing a marketing partner: FAQ

01What's the difference between a home service marketing agency and a regular marketing agency?+

A home service marketing agency works only with trades such as roofing, HVAC and plumbing, so its campaigns, landing pages and follow-up are built for how homeowners hire contractors. A generalist agency serves many industries.

02Is it better to hire an in-house marketer or an agency?+

One in-house marketer rarely covers paid search, Local Services Ads, SEO, AEO, social ads and automation well. An agency gives you a team for each channel; a large company may eventually want both.

03Are shared leads worth it for contractors?+

They can fill gaps, but shared leads are often sold to several contractors at once, so you compete on speed and price. Marketing you own — rankings, reviews and your own ad accounts — keeps producing calls without paying per lead to a marketplace.

04How do I choose a home service marketing agency?+

Look for home service focus, in-house specialists, month-to-month terms, ownership of your accounts, tracking tied to booked jobs, and real client results you can verify.

Built exclusively for home service companies

Want the full system without the hiring?

Book your free growth strategy call ↗Call (516) 206-2802

✓ Free marketing & competitor audit✓ Custom growth roadmap✓ Zero obligation